BDS How-To · Legal Defence

Lawfare

Using the law as a weapon of war

The right to stand for justice is under attack.

Visit this interactive website on US Legislation targeting advocacy for Palestinian rights

Find out more
Attacking BDS through accusations of antisemitism

De-legitimizing BDS even if it is legal

One of the charges leveled against boycott, divestment and sanctions is that it is antisemitic. This is a tool used to de-legitimize BDS, even though BDS is supported by international law.

Backgrounder on Efforts to Redefine Antisemitism as a Means of Censoring Criticism of Israel Palestine Legal, a USA-based NGO has prepared this background paper which may be helpful in other global contexts. While it cites US laws, the basic legal principles can be applied in other international situations.

Those who advocate against Palestine use the International Holocaust Remembrance Association’s (IRHA) guidelines to undercut BDS and challenge definitions.

The IRHA has actively promoted and worked legislatively in the global context to have countries adopt their “working definition” of antisemitism which effectively makes any criticism of the policies of the State of Israel an “antisemitic” action. It has encouraged the use of this definition to undercut pro-BDS activities, policies and legislation under the guise of stopping the expansion of antisemitism hate speech, human rights violations and discrimination and crimes against humanity.

In response, 240 Jewish & Israeli scholars, responding to the German Bundestag’s attack on BDS in 2019:
“The three main goals of BDS – ending the occupation, full equality to the Arab citizens of Israel and the right of return of Palestinian refugees – adhere to international law... We are shocked that demands for equality and compliance with international law are considered anti-Semitic”.

All organizations working on BDS-related advocacy should be aware of this definition and the advocacy of IRHA in their respective governments. Here are some of the governmental actions which have taken place as a result of the IRHA definition advocacy. Most of these contexts are either European or North American.

It is strongly encouraged that further research into the advocacy of applying the IRHA definition to one’s country or local context (including municipalities) be part of the legal dimensions of a BDS advocacy or action program.

Applicable in any global context

General legal and constitutional issues

Legal and constitutional issues have arisen around the BDS Movement. Nations and political jurisdictions may have different views on the BDS Movement, and if legal issues arise in your context, you should check with human rights and/or constitutional lawyers in your jurisdiction.

There are laws or resolutions which shape the framework for engaging in BDS actions in all types of jurisdictions, including municipalities, provinces or states and nations. BDS is a classic political expression of which some particular state disapproves, and this violates many countries’ constitutional or other foundational legal documents’ provisions.

An additional resource to be used cautiously
Wikipedia page on BDS — NOTE: The citations on the Wikipedia page on Boycott, Divestment and Sanctions are subject to user editing. For this reason, further verification by users is needed.